Wii Fanboy review: Wii Play

Upon inserting the Wii Play disc into your Wii's disc drive, you might feel elation and experience the levels of bliss only known to the few who would actually go on to write a sentence this long about some mundane physical exertion such as placing a disc into an electronic device. It's OK, we felt the same way too, and in being greeted with the snazzy music that accompanies the game's logo in the Disc Channel of your Wii, you might feel as if your life is about to change.

Well, this is where your hopes, which have soared to heights that have only before this point in time been reachable by large mechanical vessels with wings, come crashing back to the ground with so much momentum that it has leveled your entire city block. It's OK, look out your window, we'll wait ...
... done? Great! Oh, and yes, that's your car smoking in the center of the massive crater.

Now that we've taken up the requisite amount of time (47 seconds FYI) introducing our review for Wii Play, we should probably get around to reviewing it, wouldn't you say? See, at the title screen, the game very much looks like Wii Sports, and even promises some of the same thrills through its combination of 9 different mini-games. Only problem is, not even a one of these mini-games are close to the fun that one can have with Wii Sports: Bowling.

It all starts with you setting up your Mii and selecting the amount of players. From here, you're only able to access the first mini-game, which sadly is the Duck Hunt clone mini-game Shooting Range. I say sadly because this is honestly the best mini-game throughout the bunch, so placing it first really leaves the rest of the game's boring mini-games coming out of the ordeal looking that much more lackluster. And while, in comparison, Wii Play's 9 different mini-games might seem to hold more quality through its quantity over Wii Sports' 5 different sporting activities, the grim truth is that Wii Play is kind of like the awkward little brother to Wii Sports; not so popular at parties and less interesting in conversation.
So what other mini-games are there bundled in this tech demo game? Well, you have Tanks!, which is the runner-up for best game of the bunch. Here, each player moves their tank with the Wiimote's d-pad (or you can hook up the nunchuk attachment if you wish), navigating the battlefield whilst aiming with the Wiimote and firing your cannon. You also have a back-up attack that lets you lay mines with the A button. Of course, the rub lies in the fact that bullets travel really slow and with ever-moving enemies, you'll have to have some foresight if you wish to come out of the battle the victor.

Other noteable titles include the Laser Hockey mini-game, which is best described as pong on steroids. It's really hard to control your paddle and the combination of lights could give someone a mighty big headache after awhile. In retrospect, it would've been better if Nintendo asked us to hold the Wiimote pointing up and we raised and/or lowered it in response to our virtual paddle in-game. Instead, we're left pointing it at the screen in an awkward fashion which feels like everything but normal. Also, there's ping-pong, which is fun save for the fact that you cannot control hitting the ball and instead are charged with pointing where the ball is going to be, which lets the game take over the rest of the work. Once you start getting into vollies that range 50+ strong, it's incredibly tough to keep the streak going and the ball is flying about the table at ridiculous speeds. It would've been nice if Nintendo let you back away from the table more to compensate.
Still though, in the end the product does what it says it will do: train you how to use the Wiimote. And through the blurbs of text and mini-games you're presented with, you actually do learn how the Wiimote works and how one should go about using it. So in that regard, Wii Play passes with flying colors, accurately displaying the ergonomics of gesture-based gameplay to the player and promising that, in the future, all games using the Wiimote won't be as shallow as this one is.

For the sum of $49.99, however, it's just not worth it. Once you've beaten Wii Play, you don't really feel the need to come back to it. None of the games played were fun enough to warrant that. One shouldn't be looking at this package as a free Wiimote with a game, rather looking to the Wiimote for the initial appeal and considering that an almost-free game might be worth the ticket for admission. This, however, shouldn't be the case for the majority of you, as Nintendo replenishes stock of its hardware on the regular from here on out.
While we would like to say that these mini-games are what you would hope for from Nintendo (products that were lovingly made over time and convey the strictest standards of Nintendo to ensure fun for the end user), we'd be lying if we did. These are half-baked games that, in all honesty, should have been available to the public near the console's launch, or even been bundled with the system. Instead, we're asked to pay the same price for this package as we would a masterpiece like The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.

It's not that we're saying the game doesn't have its merits. There are times, during Shooting Range and Tanks! where we actually had a little fun, but there is nothing in this package that allows us to set its bar to anything higher than mediocre. For $10 US, we can't even say the software is worth that price.
Final Score: 4.5/10









Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Bad Mojo @ Feb 20th 2007 10:52AM
Seriously... the games aren't deep, but they can be enjoyable if you aren't expecting epic uberness. I find them a nice distraction and fun for a quick 2P smackdown...
My BIG question is:
How do I disable the frickin' "help" menu that appears during the fishing game? I can;t even see the pond to fish...
a stale altoid @ Feb 20th 2007 11:05AM
Wait, so people were actually expecting a great game?
I bought this for the extra remote, so the simple extra minigames were a nice bonus. I feel sorry for anyone foolish enough to have anticipated otherwise.
Truth be told, I liked Tanks and Find Mii. Also, this game is more fun in general when played with other people.
Fishing, Billiards, and Pose Mii kind of sucked, but the only thing that truly disappointed me was the absence of a 3-D Duck Hunt remake. Yes, Shooting Range is okay, and it does sort of allude to Duck Hunt with the way-too-fast bonus ducks and the clay pigeon level, but I want a version that is true to the original game. With virtually all of the graphics, sound, and engine already implemented, how hard would it have been to make a genuine Duck Hunt mode?
Then again, perhaps they did put it on as a secret. Though I can hardly call that a consolation prize for getting gold medals on every game.
Onier @ Feb 20th 2007 11:25AM
"should have been available to the public near the console's launch"
Wii Play worked out fine in Europe, at least for me. Bought it with the console at launch and learned how to use Wiimote with it. ..North America got it way too late.
John H. @ Feb 20th 2007 11:32AM
I needed the other Wiimote so the game was $10 which is about what it's worth. I actually like the Billiards and am surprised you guys didn't mention it.
Loban @ Feb 20th 2007 11:34AM
"Instead, we're asked to pay the same price for this package as we would a masterpiece like The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess."
I thought it came with a wiimote. Wiimotes are $40, and this package is $50. So doesn't that mean you're only paying $10 for Wii play? I'd say it's worth $10.
Smithy @ Feb 20th 2007 11:42AM
Everyone keeps defending their purchase by saying they needed an extra remote. Here's an idea: why not just buy the remote without the stinking game and save yourself 10 bucks?
Don @ Feb 20th 2007 12:11PM
I think this game is being overly slagged a wee bit (wii bit?). Perhaps I my family are too much of 'casual gamers' (feel free to read that with a sneer) but we have been having a lot of fun with it. It is possible that kids (and people like me that are easily amused) find it more enjoyable. It is certainly not 'immersive' but I find some of the games a lot of fun -- usually the ones where things blow up.
In addition to it appealing to a younger demographic, many of those that slag it are comparing it to a 'full priced' game, versus the small premium you pay. To put things in perspective, this premium is about the same price as a N64 Virtual Console game. I think it is a great value.
Ricky @ Feb 20th 2007 12:15PM
Did anyone else think that the Wiimote they gave you seemed a little cheaper than the original? I also think people that played online pool will like the billiards game the best. Also, the second game where you look for Miis can be fun in big groups.
Sihylm @ Feb 20th 2007 12:22PM
at 6
Um, maybe because Wiimotes were sold out everywhere here? Hmm? Moron.
realstar @ Feb 20th 2007 12:32PM
I had a lot of fun with WiiPlay playing 2 player on ping-pong and laser-hockey. A lot of these games are basically remade Atari 2600 titles, simple but fun for everyone.
Alexander @ Feb 20th 2007 12:52PM
I enjoy Tanks, Find Mii and Billiards.
Playing Wii Play by yourself is pretty boring but wait.. why do you think it came with an extra remote?
it is definitivly worth the $10.
Ryan D. @ Feb 20th 2007 1:15PM
No qualms whatsoever for me. I put off buying a second remote (being as all of my friends had theirs anyway) for this game, and I don't regret it. Haven't even had the chance to play it yet because it hasn't yet been delivered.. but I got $10 off and free shipping so... I bought a remote and got a nifty game with it for free.
Smithy @ Feb 20th 2007 1:26PM
@ Sihylm
I'm just saying it's OK to wait until Wiimotes get restocked instead of buying one with this game since it may not justify the $50 price tag. No need to call me a moron.
Sonic @ Feb 20th 2007 1:31PM
Tanks! alone is worth 10 bucks. All the others are really fun and challenging especially Find Mii. People just bitch to bitch really. $40 remote you dont own, plus $10 for a couple hours of decent entertainment vs 10 for a movie ticket. Hmm, people really do take everything for granted. Me and my friends played 3 hours yesterday going back and forth through different mini games. I definitely plan on going back and playing again, and all I would have to pay is $10 bucks, that's a dime bag worth of entertainment.
If this was on the VC and cost 1000 points not a word of complaint would be found by anyone.
Also I'm in complete agreement with the Atari reference, these are remakes of original atari and early NES games. Much costing far more when they were released.
KiwiNick @ Feb 20th 2007 3:17PM
Americans just wont not believe the hype. PAL users have been saying for months, 'dont get too excited, its a $10 add on etc" then all reviewers are 'disapointed'.
It is easily worth $10, (its actually NZ$10, which is like $US7).
The shooting is fun, find a mii is fun, in fact most are fun for one round.
That is 2p or course.
Stfan @ Feb 20th 2007 3:45PM
Why the hell is everyone seeming to be waiting for a great game when purchasing Wii Play. Actually you are not purchasing Wii Play. You are purchasing a Wiimote, and you get Wii Play almost for free with it. That is all. Wii Play is not a real game, it's a series of minigames that you get with your extra Wiimote. Stop the reviews please, this is ridiculous.
Bad Mojo @ Feb 20th 2007 3:54PM
Seriously.... can anyone help me out on getting rid of the fishing "help" menu? See comment 1 for clarification?
Shogan @ Feb 20th 2007 4:14PM
4.5 out of 10? On some level I guess that is fair. But we have gaming parties nearly every weekend and Wii Play got MUCH more interest than Wario Ware Smooth Moves ever did.
Sure it's not Wii Sports, but I see it as a $10 game you get in addition to getting an extra Wiimote. If you don't need an extra wiimote, then $50 for this game is way to high.
Still, I can't help but think that ALL of these games should have had some more options. 4-player would have been great, especially as a VS mode in Tanks, and the Shooting Range could have been more... well just more.
But if you're buying a Wii, get Wii Play as your second game, second controller. Definitely.
Ethan @ Feb 20th 2007 4:50PM
I don't know why everyone gives a fun $10 game a bad rating, but here are my thoughts:
I have 3 remotes now (2 without wiiplay) and enjoy playing 3-player games now. I think all of these games are fun, (especially cow racing, someone fell of the couch while playing it once) and that if you need an extra wii remote you should get this game.
Zan @ Feb 20th 2007 4:51PM
That's what we said!!
Jayenkai @ Feb 20th 2007 5:29PM
It's a shame that the Tanks game can't be played in 2 player Vs mode, like the Atari classic Combat. That disappointed me more than anything else on offer.
Oh, no. Tell a lie. That stupid bubble game sucks.
Some of the games are quite fun in "Hold both wiimotes" mode.
And, honestly, would you actually pay for a full-on Duck Hunt game, given that you have both this version and the Shoot the Cans game in Wario Ware?
Chyld989 @ Feb 20th 2007 5:50PM
"From here, you're only able to access the first mini-game, which sadly is the Duck Hunt clone mini-game Shooting Range. I say sadly because this is honestly the best mini-game throughout the bunch, so placing it first really leaves the rest of the game's boring mini-games coming out of the ordeal looking that much more lackluster."
While Shooting Range is fun, the rest of the games are boring by no means. The only game I (and most of the 7 people I know that have Wii Play) don't really care for is Billiards.
"It's really hard to control your paddle"
"Instead, we're left pointing it at the screen in an awkward fashion which feels like everything but normal."
Really? Hard to control? Just point it where you want to go. There's absolutely nothing awkward about it. If they had done any other method of control (such as the one you suggested) the game would have been horrible. Instead it is a fantastic game of air-hockey, without the added space you'd need for an air-hockey table.
"Once you start getting into vollies that range 50+ strong, it's incredibly tough to keep the streak going and the ball is flying about the table at ridiculous speeds. It would've been nice if Nintendo let you back away from the table more to compensate."
50+? Sure, it's faster, but it's definitely not "ridiculous speeds." 80+ and 125+, now those are fast. 50+ makes me think you tried each game once and then felt you were educated enough to toss out this review.
"For the sum of $49.99, however, it's just not worth it. Once you've beaten Wii Play, you don't really feel the need to come back to it. None of the games played were fun enough to warrant that."
That's like saying that once you've beaten Zelda there's no need to play it again. It's still a very enjoyable game, and even after getting all platinums I find myself playing it almost every day.
"These are half-baked games that, in all honesty, should have been available to the public near the console's launch, or even been bundled with the system."
Yes, it would have been nice if the game had come out at launch, especially since now most people already have 4 Wii Remotes, and so they're reluctant to buy this. But it didn't...
"For $10 US, we can't even say the software is worth that price."
I bought this game when I already had 4 Wii Remotes, and the $50 it cost would have hurt a little. I managed to get it used for $20, and I feel like I got a deal. This game is worth at least $30, maybe more.
"Final Score: 4.5/10"
I swear, it just feels like you played each of these minigames once (or maybe even just watched someone else play them once), and then wrote this review. No, first you vomited, and then your vomit wrote this review. While it was definitely not as in depth as Zelda, Wii Play is a fantastic game that is a lot of fun. My only major complaint is that there should have been support for 4 players in some of the games (like Tanks!...heck, at that point it could have even been just the 4 players in a free-for-all).
My final score: 8.0/10
Vale @ Feb 21st 2007 12:34AM
Considering that buying Wii Play was the ONLY way I could get a second remote for my recntly purchased Wii I thought it was a bargin.
Kenny @ Feb 21st 2007 1:21AM
"The only game I (and most of the 7 people I know that have Wii Play) don't really care for is Billiards."
Funny... I consider billiards to be one of the strongest games on Wii Play and the one I've given most time to.
Chyld989 @ Feb 21st 2007 1:56AM
"Funny... I consider billiards to be one of the strongest games on Wii Play and the one I've given most time to."
Not sure about the others, but the main reason I don't like it is because it's so freaking tough to get a platinum. I basically just got lucky one time and happened to get 3 in on the break, and 2 in on the next 2 shots...made things MUCH easier.
I love the gameplay itself though. Lets me know I'd like a pool game if it had the same controls...and as long as it was regular pool and not that nine-ball crap ^_~
Raycer @ Feb 22nd 2007 9:05AM
I bought wii play and am a bit disappointed as well. I knew it was just minigames but I figured it would be more entertaining, like Wii Sports. The games really just aren't that fun. They lack the replay value that Wii Sports has. Ironically, I find the best game to play 2 player on it is the cow racing, and even that wears thin fairly quick.
Is it worth the $10 over the Wii mote? Probably, but if you don't need another Wii mote, it's not worth running out to buy, which unfortunately I did.
M @ Feb 23rd 2007 12:44PM
I like Wii Play, even if it lacks any real depth. It's simple, easy to pick up, and great to play with other people. I didn't really need a 3rd controller, but I bought Wii Play nonetheless because it's something I can pick up and play with someone who doesn't play videogames.
DarthVictor @ Feb 26th 2007 12:02PM
well I got it for the wiimote, and $10 for 9 mini games I think it is worth it. They are great to just go in and play with friends, like last night I had friends come over, in the gap between dinner and movie out. had Great fun playing those.
Love:
Tanks, Cow Racing, Laser Hockey
Hate:
Fishing, Pose Mii
So so:
billiards, Shooting Range, Find Mii, Table Tennis